This question arises again and again. If a permanent solution is not found, it can pose grave threat to the unity of the country.
I am not going get into which language is the richest, oldest or most spoken. I am going to write from a dispassionate and objective point of view.
Let’s admit learning an additional language for most people is difficult. To attain expertise and fluency to speak in public, write official documents or to pass competitive examinations in even harder. For many of us English is like a second tongue on par with the first. For a non-native speaker mastering English is an extremely daunting task.
Think of yourself as living in a remote hamlet in the western ghats. Your son goes to the only school in the village. A government run, Kannada medium school. Yes, they teach both English and Hindi. Teachers of both these languages are ill qualified, non-native individuals who are themselves not fluent. What your son learns in this school is some form of Kinglish and Khindi. He does not ever use these languages in his daily life. By the time he gets out of school, he is proficient in neither of these two languages.
When it is time get a college education, he realizes all higher education is in English. You put him through coaching classes. He works doubly hard and comes to acquire English language skills at functional level.
He gets into college. Still, he finds the courses hard. Overtime his English language skills improve. After graduation, he finds a well paying job. The language used at work is, of course, English.
You are all happy. After all the hard work, your son is doing well. Congratulations.
Unfortunately, all kids aren't that lucky. In fact, most do not succeed. They drop out after high school find employment in the informal sector. Most of those who manage to go to college don't do all that well. They end up with jobs that are less than satisfactory.
What is the reason that most rural students are less than successful?
Isn't it because there are absolutely no jobs for Kannada experts? Did whatever he learned of Hindi any use to him? Wouldn't it have been better if more emphasis was paid to English language proficiency than wasting precious time on learning languages that one may never ever use. For these kids learning Hindi is as difficult as learning English. But, ultimately, at least, they benefit from the knowledge of English.
If Hindi, or Sanskrit for that matter, is made compulsory without creating a massive body of qualified teachers and subsequent employment opportunities, you are condemning half the children in the country to poverty.
On top of that, the Hindi taught is Doordarshan Hindi! At least, Bollywood Hindi has some use.
Coming back to the question at hand. Yes. South Indians should come together oppose the central government’s language policy not just because it is insanely unfair but more so because it adversely affects the livelihood of our future generations. Education is a serious matter. It has a large bearing on not only personal but also overall national growth and development.
These policies are having destructive impact on backward and weaker sections of society. Most of the wealthy and upper caste people avail English education. Such policies amount to sentencing a huge section of society to perpetual backwardness.
It must be a fundamental right of every family and every student to choose what they learn.
Our political class is more blind than shortsighted. Politics of language and religion will destroy the country.
If not for Any other reson , just because Southern States are generating Money, that north is wasting spending on spread of Hindi . Here are some interesting facts
Who Generates Money for India ?
- GDP cotribution The South delivers a fourth of India's GDP. It is not only an economic bellwether with low unemployment, a high rate of industrialisation and a per capita GDP that is over double that of the Hindi belt, it is also leaps ahead on human development and social indicators.
- Literacy :Child development indices are double to 7 times higher than the Hindi states, literacy rates tend towards an average of 80% with a 10-point difference against the North, and accessibility to health and hygiene facilities is radically better.
- HDI : The gulf in human development is so stark that while fertility rates in the South are closer to that of Western Europe, much of the North is still getting their act together on basic issues like birthing babies without losing mothers.
- HongKong - North India: The bottom line is that the development politics of the South has made it economically comparable to Hong Kong, while the atavistic politics of the North has dropped it far down the scales in the last six decades.
How does the Central Govt Distribute that money ?
- Robin Hoodwa Govt: In essence Delhi takes(loots ?) Money from South and gives it to North .
Whats The solution ?
Secession? No. The Indian nation is sacrosanct and India only wins when all Indians have a decent life, education, health care, jobs and social dignity. All means all. Women. Dalits. Muslims. South and North. East and West.
Southern States Regional Block? Yes : The Southern states should forma regional block within India, and make center stop this loot of money, and punish South for Norths incompetency to develop.
Language
South Indians Should Learn Hindi > For What joy ? There is no tangible benefit for a South Indian kid to learn hindi , apart from the fact that if for any reason they have to work in a Central Govt Job in Northern belt. In any private Job the South Indians are surviving and infact excelling: Sundar Pichai (Google CEO) , Indira Nooyi(Pepsi CEO) , Satya nadela(Microsoft CEO)
North Indians Should Learn Southern Languages ? Yes: For their own Good, so that when north Indians kids grow up and migrate to south, for their own survival North Indian Kids should be taught atleast one southern language.
Should UPSC support regional Languages? Yes: UPSC currently supports question paper in Hindi and English (example NDA , CDS ). This puts regional language kids who did their education in their mother tongue at considerable disadvantage than a Hindi medium only kid.
Who pays for Spread of Hindi? Not South India: South India should stop center from wasting its money in nonsense pursuits of spreading Hindi.